FOREWORD I
Kinematics as a field of engineering science has been known since the
Renaissance, the time of Leonardo da Vinci. Nevertheless, it has gained the most
popularity with the development of commercial packages of CAD/CAM systems,
and as emphasized in the book, kinematics became a very efficient tool in systems
engineering, particularly for multi-degree-of-freedom mechanical systems.
So, if it is so important for designers, then how can it be used in everyday
practice, and where it possible to learn about the critical parts of that discipline?
The person who is trained on this subject is called a “kinematician” and very often
plays the role of a system engineer. There are many traditional technical
disciplines that are taught in colleges today, such as mechanical engineering,
electrical engineering, software engineering, and so on, but there are no courses in
universities where they teach a discipline called systems engineering. The main
reason for this phenomenon is that to be qualified as a system engineer, the
engineer must gain experience in many different areas. One of these areas is
knowledge of kinematics, since kinematics provides the model (even with certain
assumptions) of the mechanical system to be designed and developed. From that
perspective, this Book on Kinematics teaches the students or engineers some
specific practical “tricks” using a large variety of real examples with real
applications.
So, the first note here, is the value of this book, which is an illustration of the
main steps to be established and solved on the road to designing practically any
mechanical system.
Now, what must a modern engineer possess (in terms of knowledge and
experience) to fully and efficiently utilize all benefits of “Kinematics?” As it is
rightly stated in the Book, there are two or three disciplines that would give the
winning ticket on every project involved with multi-degree freedom systems. One
of them is the absolute fluency in the manipulation of homogeneous 4 by 4
matrices of coordinate transformation. The second topic, based on the opinion of
the author of this book, is the knowledge about different types and configurations
for kinematic pairs or joints. Based on the number of applications presented in the
book, everyone should be convinced that experience in numerical analysis,
specifically in different methods of optimization is a must.
The book demonstrates these main steps in eleven different applications with a
very detailed, almost step-by-step explanation of different strategies chosen for a
given application. It covers applications from the automotive field, robotics, and a
variety of moving platforms, including the basics for driving simulators. The most
intriguing is Chapter 11, devoted to the comparison of kinematics between
mechanical joints and human biomechanical ones, illustrated by the
temporomandibular (TMJ) joint. This justifies the title of the book “Smart
Kinematics….”
The material in this book will be very important to gain knowledge about modern
methods in mechanical engineering for undergraduates with some prerequisites in
the area of linear algebra and matrix methods. It would be very helpful to graduate
students, as well as for engineers already graduated from the university
environment.
Alex Kapelevich
President, AKGears, LLC
FOREWORD II
The question with which the Author opens the book is important and necessary.
The events that developed after the 60s of the last centuries with the advent of
Robotics posed new challenges and drew attention to old problems that were since
then thought of as merely theoretical speculation and not very significant in
practice. As an example, to find all the solutions of the 7R mechanism, which
later became a strategic issue for the efficient control of industrial robots. Issues
that highlighted the importance of Kinematics, not as a subsection of Dynamics,
but as an essential part of its foundations.
Indeed, Jack Phillips in his book Freedom in Machinery (1985) states “The study
of mechanisms is important because the geometry of mechanical motion (i.e.
Kinematics, n.d.r.) is often the crux of a real machine’s design”.
Kinematics under the impulse of new methodologies opened the field to crucial
problems such as singularities of mechanisms and their mathematical
representation, key problems to deeply understand how to control mechanical
systems effectively.
From the first pioneering works of Fydor Litvin and Joseph Duffy, important
methods of investigation were developed since the 80s that strongly contributed to
the understanding of many problems. Just to mention a few: the kinematic
analysis of both the closed chain 7R mechanism (Hong-Yu Lee and Chong-Gao
Liang) and the mechanism known as the Gough–Stewart mechanism or, more
synthetically, as 6-6 platform (Manfred Husty), have been completely solved; new
important closed chain mechanisms (mechanisms later called parallel
mechanisms) have been synthesized (Clément Gosselin); the synthesis of spatial
mechanisms has regained new vigour and interest (Michael McCarthy), and
Kinematic analysis and synthesis are increasingly applied in robotic devices for
motor rehabilitation.
The title of Gutman’s book may seem provocative and, reading the index, the
content is anomalous and very ambitious. However, reading the chapters,
gradually one realizes the value that the approach used by the Author can have on
teaching the subject to the students, the next designers.
The book stands out of the ordinary, out of the traditional way of presenting the
Kinematics to university students. Likewise unexpected things from what we are
familiar with, the first reader's reaction can be of surprise, rejection, criticism,
etc., but looking with more attention and free from prejudices, he/she can glimpse
the truest content and the potential the book can have in the high-level educational
process. However, not everything is easily acceptable, but the whole work
represents an approach to the subject absolutely worthy of serious consideration.
Putting in the foreground some applications to teach the basic concepts of
Kinematics may seem inefficient, but here lies the point. It is well known the
dualism deductive method vs inductive method. This book, indeed, combines the
two methods in an original and certainly efficient way for teachers who want to
grasp the most creative and positive aspects of both, just adapting them to their
educational realities without prejudices.
Gutman's work deals with the study of Kinematics from a completely original
point of view, very different from the traditional method consolidated in recent
decades. It tries to stimulate the interest of students, to whom the book is mainly
addressed, starting from real problems and stimulating the deepening of the theory
to better understand its application.
In essence, compared to the classic approach from theory to application, the book
moves in several cases in a reverse direction, that is, from application to theory
(inductive rather than deductive method).
The book reflects the experience of the Author, firstly a university researcher and
then a technician with a long experience gained in the world of advanced motion
simulators (in an international leading company).
After the introductory part, where the theoretical bases to deal with kinematic
analysis are exposed, the book presents the fundamental problems of a designer,
namely the optimization and the analysis of complex industrial systems, to end
with important and complex applications related to biomechanical problems.
The subject is largely presented by referring to notable industrial examples, then
gradually introducing in Chapter 2 the necessary theoretical concepts to solve the
problem at hand. Whilst Chapter 3 refers to the theory in a very general and
abstract way. Then it treats the influence of manufacturing errors on the mobility
of a mechanism, a very interesting issue, applied to the Uhing mechanism
(RCCC) taken as an example.
In general, optimization is not covered in Kinematics textbooks. The treatment of
Gutman's book in Chapter 4 does so with great clarity and usefulness for the
student, who can easily understand that a real system is always the result of an
optimization; either based on an empirical process, which is refined over the
years, or, more effectively, on mathematical models easily implemented in
computer codes that even low skilful designers can use.
Particular attention to stability, control and trajectory planning of robots is
devoted in Chapter 5, while methods for solving the position analysis of robots
with 6 degrees of freedom (dof) are exposed in Chapter 6, highlighting their most
critical aspects. A gantry system is also presented as an example to show how to
deal with the singular configurations of a mechanism. The interesting concept of
Phantom dof is introduced in Chapter 7.
Chapters 8, 9 and 10 are devoted to the analysis of complex systems (testing
machines) where the methods set out in the previous chapters are used.
Chapter 11 shows how very complex biomechanical systems (tibio femoral joint,
knee, ankle, etc.) can be modelled by kinematic elements of an equivalent
mechanism, which can be of the utmost importance to design and implement
dental prostheses, and to plan surgical interventions.
The book subject is frequently treated colloquially as if one were lecturing
students. This makes the exposition less formal, maybe less attractive for the
researcher and the professional scholar, but perhaps more accessible and
interesting for the students who deal for the first time with these concepts that are
anything but immediate (i.e. the modelling of mechanical systems (mechanisms)
and the solution of systems of nonlinear equations).
For the depth of the topics and the analytical tools used, the book should be
understood for an advanced kinematics course for Master and PhD students.
In conclusion, the book is quite different from most books on Kinematics
available on the market. It treats basic and advanced elements of the theory (as
many other books do) plus very interesting industrial applications, which are
rarely found in the academic literature.
The book represents a balanced synthesis of basic elements of three-dimensional
kinematics and examples of application from the industrial world that are very
interesting and certainly of keen interest to teachers and a stimulus for students. In
particular, students can come across with complex concepts (of kinematics),whose usefulness is frequently not fully understood, applied to the resolution of real problems of strong industrial importance, and then get tangible evidence of
their relevance.
This book provides a relevant contribution to education. It is a novelty in the
panorama of the books on mechanism Kinematics.
In my opinion, I believe that Gutman's work represents a valid tool for teachers
and provides a significant contribution to the high-level training of today's
students, who will be the designers of tomorrow.
Vincenzo Parenti Castelli
University of Bologna
Bologna, Italy